Due to the special political condition on the Korean
Peninsula - continuing ideological conflict between the two
Koreas - infringement of individual human rights for ¡°national
security reasons¡± was often seen as inevitable or even justifiable
for decades. Thanks to the ceaseless efforts of the public
and intellectuals for democratization through student, labor,
and civil movements, Korean society has witnessed explosive
changes since the 1990¡¯s. Regrettably, however, the still
unresolved national division acts to maintain a distorted
state in which the National Security Act (http://www.nis.go.kr)
exists above the Constitution, whose aim lies in protecting
the basic rights of the people.
Nevertheless, the democratization movement
of the 1980¡¯s and 1990¡¯s empowered the Korean gay community,
completely silenced and negated until then, finally to speak
up and to establish Chodong-hoe, the first gay rights activist
group in the country. Later divided into Chingusai (¡°Between
Friends¡±) Korean Gay Men¡¯s Coalition (http://chingusai.net)
and Korean Female Sexual Minorities' Rights Group Kirikiri
(http://www.kirikiri.org), it paved the way for currently
active LGBT rights activist groups such as the Lesbian and
Gay Human Rights Federation (http://outpridekorea.com),
LGBT magazine Buddy (http://buddy79.com), Korean Sexual
Minority Culture and Rights Center (http://kscrc.org), and
LGBT Korea (http://lgbt.or.kr).
Up to the 1990¡¯s, the Korean gay community
remained strictly hidden from the public. It consisted merely
of train stations, parks, and gay bars tucked away in certain
districts of large cities such as Sindang-dong and Nagwon-dong
in Seoul. The community was completely ignored or, at best,
covered by the media and the press in racy and distorted
reports. Consequently, homosexuals did not even dare to
voice their opinions. All that changed with the establishment
Chingusai (1994), which openly claimed gay rights and made
discourses on homosexuality public. What aided such changes
was the wide distribution of PC communication services and
the Internet, thanks to the government¡¯s informationalization
policy. As a result, hitherto silenced Korean homosexuals
were able to create their own space online and even to contribute
to offline activities, thus leading to the speedy expansion
of the gay community itself. Such spread of the Internet
also enabled the younger generation to establish a semi-public
gay ghetto in Itaewon, a tourist district in Seoul. Today,
homosexuality generates a variety of social discourses and
even serves as a trend in cultural codes in Korea.
Currently, the Korean gay community consists
of: LGBT rights activist groups; entertainment establishments
that cater to gay men and women such as bars and baths in
large cities (Seoul, Pusan, Taejon, Taegu, and Kwangju);
and chat rooms, personal homepages, and Internet BBS. The
rapid quantitative growth of the community online, however,
has not been accompanied by corresponding growth in quality.
Consequently, the Korean gay community is very loosely organized
and has yet to create a healthy and diverse gay culture
that promotes and protects LGBT rights. Likewise, members
of the community are highly fragmented and disparate.
Nonetheless, quantitative growth has resulted
in some noteworthy accomplishments. The record of Korean
LGBT activists¡¯ struggle against the government and existing
laws is impressive indeed. As may be expected, the Korean
gay community has not simply progressed and expanded since
the 1990¡¯s because Confucianism and Christianity, two dominant
ideologies in Korea today, continue to view homosexuality
as unnatural or ungodly. A good example is the litigation
involving Exzone (http://exzone.com), a Korean gay BBS,
which has attracted international attention. The Youth Protection
Law (Juvenile Protection Act) of Korea designates homosexuality
as ¡°harmful to minors¡± and censors the Internet, forcibly
closing gay adolescent group¡¯s online BBS and labeling their
contents as ¡°unfit for minors.¡± All LGBT rights activist
groups in Korea therefore protested against the government¡¯s
closure of Exzone and oppression of gay adolescents¡¯ Internet
sites and endeavored to demonstrate that information on
homosexuality was not harmful to juveniles. Regrettably,
however, they lost the case and are now awaiting the Constitutional
Court¡¯s (http://www.ccourt.go.kr) judgment on the constitutionality
of the Youth Protection Law.
Since then, Korean LGBT rights activist groups
have unceasingly demanded the government to drop the anti-homosexual
clause from the Youth Protection Law, which requires all
public facilities open to adolescents such as Internet cafes
to install Internet classification and censorship softwares.
Due to this very clause, numerous sites providing general
information on homosexuality or created by LGBT activist
groups have been classified as ¡°adult¡± sites and filtered
out. With Kirikiri and the LGHRF at the center, LGBT rights
activist groups therefore appealed to the National Human
Rights Commission (http://www.humanrights.go.kr) regarding
such softwares and their manufacturers and the Youth Protection
Law itself. Recently, the NHRC stated that general information
on homosexuality was not harmful to adolescents and advised
the Commission on Youth Protection (http://www.youth.go.kr),
responsible for the Youth Protection Law, to delete the
anti-homosexual clause as it was liable to infringe on individuals¡¯
basic rights. The CYP duly agreed to comply with the NHRC¡¯s
suggestion.
Except military laws on sodomy (military service
is compulsory for all able-bodied men), no Korean law even
alluded to homosexuality until the NHRC included a clause
prohibiting discrimination on the basis of an individual¡¯s
sexual orientation in the NHRC Act, legislated in 2001.
Such judiciary improvement has brought about a growing movement
for the legislation of a law specifically prohibiting discrimination
against homosexuals.
Unlike its counterparts in the West, the Korean
LGBT community has yet to experience physical violence motivated
by homophobia such as gay bashing or vandalism directed
at gay bars. This is not, however, because Korean society
accepts sexual minorities as its rightful members or is
exceptionally tolerant. Rather, the reason lies in its two-sided
attitude toward homosexuality. On one hand, some progressive
intellectuals view LGBT rights as a measure of social ¡°progress.¡±
The vast majority of the public, however, still considers
homosexuals as perpetrators of abnormal, revolting, and
subhuman sexual acts. This is because homosexuality is unmentionable
and therefore must never become visible in Korea. While
such oppression is unique in that it takes the form solely
of moral or religious criticism as opposed to physical violence,
it is all the more dangerous and harmful because it leads
to deep-rooted prejudice and thorough discrimination. Moreover,
because family honor is an extremely important value in
Korea, not a few gay men and women have been rejected and
cast out by their families after coming out to them?honesty,
unfortunately, is not always the best policy.
For these reasons, we strongly advise all LGBT
friends who visit or live in Korea never to come out within
relationships, networks, or organizations that are public,
official, professional, or related to their subsistence.
This is because you are very likely to face considerable
discrimination but social mechanisms or institutions that
can redress such discrimination are nearly non-existent.
For instance, a Korean television actor who publicly came
out in 2000 was immediately dismissed from all programs.
Of course, you may freely express your sexual orientation
among very close?and younger?friends and within the gay
community in Seoul (Jongro and Itaewon districts as the
two centers) and elsewhere.
Nevertheless, we believe that such conditions
will improve, however gradually and unnoticeably. Starting
on June 21, 2003, the 4th Korean Queer Cultural Festival
¡°Mujigae¡± (http://www.kqcf.org) will be held in Jongro and
other districts of Seoul. The event will comprise a variety
of activities including a street parade, a dance party,
an exhibition, and a queer film festival. The LGBT community
will continue to raise its voice and to win its rightful
position in Korean society.
¡ØChingusai
Korean Gay Men¡¯s Coalition
On a lighter note, we wish to clear a minor cultural difference
that may surprise uninformed LGBT friends from abroad, especially
North America. You will notice a great deal of physical
contact between Koreans of the same sex in public, particularly
between young females. Acceptable contact includes walking
arm in arm, holding hands, and touching or stroking body
parts (but, of course, not hugging or kissing). Such behavior
should not, however, be seen as a display of (homo)sexuality.
As in many other parts of the world, the unspoken social
custom in Korea dictates that physical contact between members
of the same sex only expresses friendliness and is therefore
strictly non-sexual and ¡°safe¡± (note that the slightest
possibility of homosexuality is not even imagined here).
As for touching between men and women, it is still considered
too intimate, sexual, and thus ¡°indiscreet¡± or ¡°dangerous,¡±
though young people are becoming increasingly bold about
publicly expressing affection for their (heterosexual) lovers.
Of course, such contact occurs only between close friends,
colleagues, and family members?the condition being emotional
and social closeness or equality. While Korean gay lovers
therefore are very careful about their public behavior,
it is also possible for them to engage in physical contact
openly since they can say, ¡°We¡¯re just friends.¡±